Maritime History Meets Modern Comfort at the Carriage House in Old Mystic, CT! | House in Old Mystic CT

Image your whimsical hideout featuring 4 artful, nautically themed ensuite private rooms on the main floor and a charming 2BR apt above. Near the head of the Mystic River, the Carriage House is your perfect quiet spot to relax from the bustle~ just 3 miles from downtown Mystic's attractions. Whether it's a couple's retreat, a wedding party, or a friends' meet-up, we can tailor your visit to ensure an unforgettable experience for you and your group!
Hospitality as sweet as apple pie!
The Carriage House, once an annex to the Old Mystic Inn, uniquely offers four individual private guest rooms with private baths and entrances on the first floor with a separate exterior entrance to the 2nd-floor 2BR apartment. Guests in your group staying in the 1st-floor private rooms will need to walk outside under the covered roof to access the 2BR apartment above to use the kitchen, dining area, and living room.
This configuration is unique for groups as it allows guests to stay in the private rooms on the first floor, which have private bathrooms and entrances, a little more autonomy and privacy.
We're delighted you found us and would love a moment to share what's special about this property!
A LITTLE HISTORY
The 1784 Denison Home, the antique red colonial on this property, built by John Denison, a prominent family name who settled in colonial Mystic was a hat maker by trade (or did he ever become a “mad hatter?”) The 1st floor of this home was most likely a hat store while he lived there.
Once upon a time, a gentleman named Vincent bought this special property and opened the Old Mystic Bookstore in the Denison Home. Vincent specialized in obscure 1st edition books and maritime maps~ housing over 20,000-30,000 pieces. The locals remember the bookstore well and said you could hardly move through the rooms as books and maps rambled along on all surfaces from top to bottom, but Vincent always knew where his books and maps were when a customer put in a request. You can still see his maps preserved in the Denison Home's front hallway to this day.
This wonderful property was renovated into a bed & breakfast, the Old Mystic Inn, and that's when the Carriage House, this listing, was built to accommodate additional guests traveling to Mystic. The Old Mystic Inn welcomed guests for 33 years until 2019, when Michael, chef and last innkeeper, served his last guests his famous scrumptious breakfast.
This dear property has much history and many stories to tell over its 250 years and is meant to continue to open its doors to visitors who desire to experience a piece of that history, too! If only walls had ears, imagine the stories they could recount. Perhaps you can listen and hear the walls whisper words of the past!
HOUSE HIGHLIGHTS
* Nautical touches, antiques, modern amenities, and an eye for detail fill each room
* Perfect set up for family and friend gatherings
* 4 ensuite private 1st-floor guest rooms
* Having separate exterior entrances is excellent for added privacy
* 2nd floor 2 BR apartment
* Fully equipped apartment kitchen
* All 1st-floor private guest rooms have a mini fridge and coffee station in each room
* Central Mystic location to attractions and the Mystic River
* Nautical books and curiosities throughout
* New super comfy Casper memory foam mattresses and fresh pillows
* New 32" TVs in every 1st floor bedroom
* New apartment TV with L-shaped comfy couch for movie night
* High-speed internet
* Whimsical nautical murals in each guest room
* Outdoor firepit
* Multiple outdoor seating areas
* Plenty of parking available~ up to 5 spaces in the driveway
LIVING & ENTERTAINING
When your group wants to gather, you'll have a comfy, inviting living room in the apartment with a brand new 50" Sony TV, a large L-shaped couch, lots of pillows, throws, a wingback chair, and a desk with a chair for anyone who needs to get a little work done.
COOKING & DINING
The 2nd-floor apartment's adorable galley kitchen is fully equipped with everything you need to whip up fabulous meals during your stay~ and refreshed with brand-new appliances.
A large round table seats up to 8 guests, and plenty of dishes and cloth napkins are available. Whether you want to come together as a group to enjoy laughter, love, and conversation or take some ‘you’ time in a relaxing, private guest room, there is space for everyone.
SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS
Four ensuite 1st-floor private bedrooms plus a 2-bedroom 2nd-floor apartment
In honor of the Mystic's maritime heritage, we named our guest rooms after New England maritime figures.
All guest rooms feature historically themed Susan Leach murals, new Casper memory foam mattresses, fresh pillows and beautiful linens, 32” Smart TVs with Roku Stick, alarm clocks with sleep sounds, bedaside USB charger ports, plenty of soft fluffy towels, and complimentary toiletries so that you can pack lighter.
Bedroom 1: Life Saver (1st-floor)
Sleeps 2: queen bed, closet, work desk, coffee station, gas stove (October-April), cozy sitting area for two, and an ensuite full bath.
Bedroom 2: Salty Sailor (1st-floor)
Sleeps 2: queen bed, dresser, desk, coffee station, sitting area for two, and an ensuite full bath.
Bedroom 3: Rigger Room (1st-floor)
Sleeps 2: queen bed, dresser, coffee table with two chairs, gas fireplace (seasonal Oct-April), coffee station, and ensuite full bath with a shower/single-person whirlpool tub.
Bedroom 4: Whaler Room (1st-floor)
Sleeps 2-4 queen-size bed and antique full-size bed, dresser, desk, a gas fireplace (October-April), cozy sitting area for two, and an ensuite full bathroom with shower/single-person whirlpool tub.
Bedroom 5: Apartment Queen Room (2nd floor)
Sleeps 2: cozy reading nook, closet, dresser, mirror
Bedroom 6: Apartment Full Room (2nd floor)
Sleeps 2: dresser, mirror, closet
STAIRWAY
All four private guest rooms are on the 1st floor and require NO stairs to access. You'll access the 2nd-floor apartment through another exterior door to a hallway that leads to the stairwell for the apartment.
OUTDOOR SPACES
You'll enjoy four little tables and chairs under the covered porch for morning coffee, evening wine, or getting caught up on a little office work on those mild days. Relax in the side yard around the fire pit (bundle of wood provided), furnished with 6 Adirondack chairs and two hammocks~ feel free to move chairs from the front porch to the firepit to accommodate more seating~ lightweight and easy to move. You're welcome to the Gazebo in the front yard, a shared space with our Denison Home guests. You'll love the old maple tree, the shade it provides in the summer, and the outstanding color in autumn.
FAMILIES
At the Carriage House, we love to welcome children! Parents and grandparents often share how their kiddos enjoyed the nautical theme, too!
You’ll find a high chair, pack-n-play for little guests, and plenty of board games for family time.
LOCATION
Located in the hamlet of Old Mystic at the head of the Mystic River, the Carriage House is just a 3-mile ride to the Mystic Seaport, shops, and restaurants. Enjoy seaport history and walk or bike on the scenic River Road just around the corner.
Haley's Way Playground and Field is just a hop, skip, and jump behind the property- a great place to bring the kids to play.
Quaint is an understatement and central to everything! Launch your Kayak a short distance away. There's an amazingly friendly post office across the street and an antique shop open Friday-Sunday, where you never know what treasure you will find. Our town is quiet at night and a great respite from the bustle of DT Mystic. If you are in town on a Sunday, you may even hear the sound of Church bells as you rise for your morning coffee.
Do you desire a day to just relax after traveling? Make a to-go lunch, grab some takeout and one of our blankets, and have lunch on our lawn under the big Maple trees.
If you enjoy walking, jogging, or biking, we have complimentary bikes available as part of your getaway, the scenic River Road is just around the corner across the little bridge. (Please note: bikes are seasonal and subject to availability)
Ready to go out and explore? Spend a day at the Mystic Seaport Museum and immerse yourself in maritime history. See the ships and buildings that inspired our room names at the Carriage House, the 1784 Denison Home, and Williams & Smith Cottage next door~ you need to board the Charles W. Morgan, the last whaleship left!
Spend a day exploring the Mystic Aquarium and make a date with one of the Beluga Whales.
Craving a beach day? Pack one of our beach bags and towels and head to a local beach or one of Rhode Island's beaches, easily accessible within a 15-minute drive.
Rent a kayak or paddleboard and spend time exploring Mystic from the Mystic River!
Venture out to one of the wineries or breweries for an afternoon sip and taste.
Do you crave a bit of nature during your Mystic stay? Walk one of the many scenic farms nearby.
During the fall months, you'll be a stone’s throw from BF Clyde’s Cider Mill, the oldest steam-powered cider mill in the country. This special mill draws crowds to see the steam engine in action, and taste the freshest apple cider and apple cider donuts, too!
Whether you need relaxation or activity, Mystic offers both!
LARGER GROUPS?
In addition to the Carriage House apartment and four charming 1st-floor private guest rooms, which can accommodate up to 14 guests, we have two adjacent properties in Old Mystic for larger group gatherings; the Denison Home, Williams Home, and Smith Cottage~ among the properties, we can host up to 38 guests.
Book your stay now! You'll be delighted you did, and we'll be delighted to host you!
Warmly,
Debbie & Paul
Mystic Vacation Rentals LLC

Maritime History Meets Modern Comfort at the Carriage House in Old Mystic, CT! is located in Stonington. Maritime History Meets Modern Comfort at the Carriage House in Old Mystic, CT! provides accommodation, featuring Child Friendly, Parking, View, among other amenities. This House features Child Friendly, Parking, View, to make your stay a comfortable one.

Maritime History Meets Modern Comfort at the Carriage House in Old Mystic, CT! has 6 Bedrooms , 5 Bathrooms, and max occupancy of 14 people. The minimum rental for this property is 1 nights, but this can change depending on the season you plan on staying. Previous guests have given good rated it, and VRBO labeled it a top-rated House because of the excellent services rendered by the owner or manager of this House, and has consistently provided great experiences for their guests. Most families or guests that use it recommend it to their friends and some of them are repeat guests. House has a friendly neighborhood, and the Stonington has interesting places to visit. If you want to learn more about the House in Stonington, such as places to visit and things to do nearby, you can check below to learn more.