Alligator Reef Light Suite | House in Key West

Escape the Ordinary...
The Alligator Reef Lighthouse Suite offers separate King and Queen bedrooms and was completely refurbished in 2024, sleeping up to 6 guests. This beautifully appointed ground floor suite, located in a renovated 1930’s Historic Key West building, offers a private exterior entrance and a spacious private front porch with Key West Lighthouse and partial Duval Street views tucked away on a quiet Key West Lane. The Suite is located steps away from the two brand new oasis pools and brand-new amenities on the property.
Suite Amenities:
• Luxury queen beds with premium linens
• Queen sleeper sofa
• Fully equipped kitchen with granite countertops
• Spa quality stone rain shower bathroom
• Hardwood flooring throughout the suite
• Spacious front porch with lighthouse and partial Duval St. views
• Smart TVs with the latest Roku device for apps and streaming
• High-speed Fiber Wi-Fi
• Washer and dryer
• Luxury well-appointed furnishing and artwork
• Reserved parking space for one vehicle
Location:
The Alligator Reef Lighthouse Suiteoffers the perfect blend of convenience and tranquility, located just a half-block from world-famous Duval Street. While you’re steps away from the vibrant energy of Key West’s best shops, restaurants, and nightlife, the resort is tucked away on a peaceful, picturesque lane, providing a quiet retreat. The iconic Hemingway House Museum, just behind the property, is only a 2-minute walk away, and Fort Zachary Taylor Park and Beach are also within easy walking distance. Experience the best of both worlds—close to the action, yet an oasis of peace and quiet.
About the Property:
Welcome to The Lighthouse Suites Collection, an exclusive six-unit luxury vacation rental resort offering in the heart of historic Old Town Key West. Just steps from Duval Street and a short walk to Fort Zachary Taylor Park beach, our location places you at the center of Key West’s most iconic attractions and vibrant nightlife.
The Lighthouse Suites Collection is truly one of a kind. This mini resort is defined by its luxurious suites, on-site parking, and exceptional location. Our immaculate 5-star accommodations are enhanced by a unique outdoor experience featuring two tropical oasis pools with spacious pool decks, a pergola with a cozy seating area and fire pit, and a fully equipped outdoor kitchen and BBQ grill with a Brio filtered water and ice maker station.
Whether you’re planning a romantic escape, a memorable family vacation, or an unforgettable group retreat, The Lighthouse Suites Collection offers the ultimate Key West experience, blending luxury, comfort, and first-class amenities.
In January 2025, we completed a full renovation of our outdoor common areas, exclusively accessible to guests of our six suites.
The property now features two brand-new oasis plunge pools, each with its own sundeck, offering the perfect spot to sunbathe or unwind by the pool. Guests can relax on our teak chaise loungers or indulge in one of our two luxury double chaise cabanas. We also added a 200-square-foot pergola, separated into two areas: one half features a cozy seating area with a swing and fire pit, perfect for enjoying an elegant evening cocktail. The other half houses a fully equipped outdoor kitchen, complete with a BBQ, sink, and two refrigerators. To top it off, the kitchen includes a Brio filtered water and ice maker system to keep you hydrated on warm Key Westdays.
Property Amenities:
• Two brand-new heated oasis plunge pools, each with waterfalls and pool shower
• Brand-new spacious pool decks around each pool
• Six luxury teak chaise loungers with umbrellas and pillows
• Two brand-new double chaise luxury resort cabanas seating two guests each
• Two in-pool chaise ledge loungers to sunbathe and cool off simultaneously
• A brand-new 200 SF teak pergola with a louvered open or closed ceiling
• Luxury couch and daybed swing under the pergola with an elegant fire pit
• Fully equipped outdoor bar, BBQ grill with a sink and fridge under the pergola
• Covered bar kiosk for enjoying a cocktail
• Key West tropical foliage throughout the property with lighted step-stone paths
• Exclusive on-street parking spaces with room for six vehicles and 1 per suite
• Schlage smart lock security on all Suites and gate access to the property
Group Accommodation:
If you need more room for your party, contact us about renting one or more Suites for your stay. We have 2 two-bedroom Suites, 3 one-bedroom Suites, a 1 one-bedroom bungalow and our largest one-bedroom one and a half bath Honeymoon Suite, accommodating a maximum of 28 guests. Our property is perfect for weddings, other large gatherings, and events.
Frequently Asked Questions:
1. Are the pools and amenities shared?
Yes, the 6 Suites share all the amenities above which are exclusive to only guests staying with us on property and is secured with smart locks on the gate access to the property common areas.
2. What is the parking situation? Can I bring more than one vehicle?
Parking in Key West can be challenging, but we’ve made it easier for our guests. Our property includes five reserved parking spaces and one exclusive off-street parking space for the Carysfort Light Suite, all conveniently located on Eanes Lane, right next to the Suites. Each space is clearly marked with signage along the buildings.
We can accommodate one vehicle per Suite. If you rent multiple Suites, you’ll be assigned the corresponding number of parking spaces. For your convenience, a property map showing the location of all six parking spaces is included in the photos. Additionally, we will send the property and parking map in your welcome packet for easy reference.
3. Where is my Suite located?
Please refer to the property map in the pictures, which will show you the location of your Suite on the property. All three properties are adjacent to each other and the property is fenced in with smart lock gates.
• TheAlligator Reef (2BD, 1BA),American Shoal (2BD/1BA),Sombrero Reef (1BD/ 1BA), andTortugas Harbor Suites (1BD/ 1BA) are located at419 Truman Avenuein the same historic building, withSombrero ReefandTortugas Harbor Suitelocated upstairs.
• TheKey West Lighthouse Suiteis a separate individual queen bungalow with a loft featuring a queen bed, located at215 Eanes Lane.
• TheCarysfort Light Suite is a separate individual one bedroom/ one and a half bath home with its own exclusive off-street parking space, located at217 Eanes Lane.
4. Do I need a vehicle or transportation?
If you have a vehicle, we have rare parking available that most lodging on the island cannot offer but you do not need a vehicle to enjoy your stay with us. The property is located one-half block off Duval Street on quaint and quiet Eanes Lane delivering one of the best lodging locations on the Island close to everything but in a peaceful and quiet location. Here are the distances to some Key West Landmarks:
• Key West Lighthouse Museum, 2-minute walk
• Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, 2-minute walk
• Blue Heaven Restaurant, 5-minute walk
• Southernmost Point Buoy, 8-minute walk
• Key West Butterfly Conservatory, 8-minute walk
• Sloppy Joe’s Bar, 12-minute walk
• Key West Amphitheater and Park, 12-minute walk
• Mallory Square Sunset, 12-minute walk
• Fort Zachary Taylor State Park & Beach, 12-minute walk
We look forward to welcoming you to paradise!

Alligator Reef Light Suite is located in Old Town. Alligator Reef Light Suite provides accommodation, featuring Air Conditioner, Ocean View, Child Friendly, among other amenities. This House features Air Conditioner, Ocean View, Child Friendly, to make your stay a comfortable one.

Alligator Reef Light Suite has 2 Bedrooms , 1 Bathroom, and max occupancy of 6 people. The minimum rental for this property is 1 nights, but this can change depending on the season you plan on staying. Previous guests have given good rated it, and VRBO labeled it a top-rated House because of the excellent services rendered by the owner or manager of this House, and has consistently provided great experiences for their guests. Most families or guests that use it recommend it to their friends and some of them are repeat guests. House has a friendly neighborhood, and the Old Town has interesting places to visit. If you want to learn more about the House in Old Town, such as places to visit and things to do nearby, you can check below to learn more.